One of you is unsure.
If one of you is thinking about leaving and the other wants to save the relationship, discernment counselling was designed for you.
It suits couples where one partner is unsure about staying and isn’t ready to commit to couples therapy.
I see this often.
One person books the session full of hope, and their partner arrives unsure they want to be there at all.
Ordinary couples therapy struggles here, and I’ll explain why.
My own method is Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT), and it needs something this situation doesn’t have yet.
What is discernment counselling?
Discernment counselling was developed by Bill Doherty, a family therapist and professor at the University of Minnesota.
In America it’s spelled discernment counseling.
Doherty calls these mixed-agenda couples. One partner is leaning out and the other is leaning in.
The aim is for each of you to get clear and confident about what to do next, with a better understanding of how you got here and your own part in it.
It doesn’t try to repair the relationship in those few sessions.
It ends with a choice between three paths:
- stay as you are for now
- separate or divorce
- commit to six months of couples therapy, with divorce off the table for that time
What happens in a session
It’s short. The first session is two hours, and there are five sessions at most.
You only ever commit to one session at a time. At the end of each one, you each decide whether you want another.
Most of the time is spent in one-to-one conversations. The counsellor talks with each of you separately.
In between, there’s some carefully structured sharing as a couple.
The counsellor supports both positions.
The leaning-out partner isn’t pushed to stay, and the leaning-in partner gets help to bring their best self to a frightening time instead of pleading or blaming.

What the research says
The research is young, and most of it comes from Doherty’s own team.
I couldn’t find a randomised trial.
In the 2016 paper that introduced the approach, Doherty and his colleagues looked at 100 couples in a row.
About half chose couples therapy to try to reconcile, and most of the others chose to divorce.
A 2021 study surveyed 11 people who had divorced after discernment counselling and interviewed eight of them. They said it helped them be clear and honest in the decision, and that they cooperated better as co-parents afterwards.
A 2026 study of large data sets found mixed-agenda couples are common. They made up nearly 40% of couples in a therapy sample.
That last number tells you something.
If you’re in this position, you’re far from alone.
What other people say about discernment counselling
Journalist Tracy Moore, writing for MEL Magazine, explains how it differs from couples counselling.
She says it’s not meant to save the relationship: “it’s meant to determine if there’s anything worth saving”.
Therapist Nicole Arzt, writing for Choosing Therapy, sets out the limits.
It isn’t appropriate where there’s domestic violence or an immediate crisis, because safety has to come first. It also doesn’t fit when one person has already decided to leave, or when one partner is being pressured to attend.
Annabelle Psychology, a clinic in Singapore that offers it, makes a point I agree with.
The reflection is useful whether the marriage continues or ends.
How discernment counselling compares to Emotionally Focused Therapy
They do different jobs, so I see them as steps that can follow each other.
Discernment counselling helps you decide whether to work on the relationship. EFT is how I’d help you do that work once you’ve both said yes.
They share a few things.
Neither blames one partner, and both ask you to look at your own part.
- Discernment counselling is brief and mostly individual. You don’t practise new ways of talking to each other.
- EFT happens between you. It needs both of you willing to be open, and that’s hard when one of you isn’t sure you want to stay.
When both partners do commit, Emotionally Focused Therapy has good evidence.
A meta-analysis covering 20 studies and 332 couples found about 70% of couples were free of relationship distress at the end of therapy, with results holding for up to two years. More is on the EFT research page.
Which one is right for you?
Start with an honest question.
Do you both want to work on this, or does only one of you?
If you both do, even with doubts, you can go straight to couples therapy. Doubt is normal, and I’ve written about it in is couples therapy worth it?
If one of you is leaning out, a few sessions with a trained discernment counsellor may serve you better than starting therapy half-heartedly.
I’m not trained in this approach, so I’d refer you to someone who is.
If you’re the one who’s unsure, my post should I stay or should I leave? may help you think. And if your partner won’t come to therapy at all, this note for reluctant partners is one you could share.
When you’re both ready to try, you can see how I work on my couples therapy page.

Where to learn more
- Book: William Doherty and Steven Harris, Helping Couples on the Brink of Divorce: Discernment Counseling for Troubled Relationships (2017). It’s written for therapists.
- Book: Alan Hawkins, Steven Harris and Tamara Fackrell, Should I Try to Work It Out? (second edition, 2022). This one is for couples.
- Official site: discernmentcounseling.com, which has a directory of trained counsellors.
- Video: Dr. Bill Doherty Talks about Discernment Counseling, from the Doherty Relationship Institute.
Where to buy the books
- Helping Couples on the Brink of Divorce: Discernment Counseling for Troubled Relationships by William Doherty and Steven Harris: Mighty Ape, Paper Plus or Amazon
- Steven Harris and Tamara Fackrell, Should I Try to Work It Out? by Alan Hawkins: Mighty Ape, Paper Plus or Amazon
Not sure which approach is right for the two of you? Start with a free discovery call and we’ll talk about what would help you most.